• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Gerry Armstrong's Legal Archive

Scientology v. Armstrong and related cases

  • Scientology v. Armstrong
    • Armstrong Exhibits
      • Topics
    • Armstrong 1
      • Armstrong 1 Trial Transcripts (April 19 – June 8, 1984)
      • Armstrong 1 Trial Exhibits
      • Armstrong 1 Appeals
      • Correspondence in Armstrong 1 and Appeals
    • Armstrong 2
      • Armstrong 2 Appeals
      • Correspondence in Armstrong 2 and Appeals
    • Armstrong 3
    • Armstrong 4
      • Armstrong 4 Appeals
      • Armstrong 4: The Record On Appeal
        • Armstrong 4 Record on Appeal: Exhibits
      • Correspondence in Armstrong 4 and Appeals
    • Armstrong 5
      • Correspondence in Armstrong 5
    • Armstrong 6
      • Armstrong 6 Appeals
      • Correspondence in Armstrong 6 and Appeals
    • Armstrong 7
      • Armstrong 7 Appeals
      • Correspondence in Armstrong 7 and Appeals
    • Armstrong 8
  • Related Cases

Declaration

OPPOSITION OF CROSS-COMPLAINANT GERALD ARMSTRONG TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF ISSUES; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT THEREOF; DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 5, 1986)

November 5, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: Julia Dragojevic, Esq.
View/Download: OPPOSITION OF CROSS-COMPLAINANT GERALD ARMSTRONG TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF ISSUES; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT THEREOF; DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 5, 1986)

 

CONTOS & BUNCH
5855 Topanga Canyon Boulevard
Suite 400
Woodland Hills, California 91367-4694
Telephone (818) 716-9400
Attorneys for Defendant and Cross-Complainant GERALD ARMSTRONG
[stamped]

ORIGINAL FILED NOV 5 – 1986
COUNTY CLERK

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY OF CALIFORNIA, a California Corporation;
Plaintiff,
vs.
GERALD ARMSTRONG, et al.,
Defendants.


AND RELATED CROSS-ACTIONS


)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
No. C 420 153
[Severed Action]

OPPOSITION OF CROSS-COMPLAINANT GERALD ARMSTRONG TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF ISSUES;  MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT THEREOF; DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG

DATE: November 19, 1986
TIME: 9:00 a.m.
DEPT: 57 

COMES NOW, cross-complainant Gerald Armstrong, and submits the following Memorandum in opposition to the Motion for Summary Adjudication of Cross-Defendant Church of Scientology of California:
///
///
///
///
///

-1-

I

THE FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION FOR FRAUD IS NOT BARRED BY THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS

Cross-defendant contends that Armstrong’s fraud allegation as to the confidentiality of auditing and the “religious” status of Scientology are barred by the three year statute of limitations. Cross-defendant,  however, has taken a “blinders” approach in its argument, choosing to look at a few statements of Armstrong and avoiding all other evidence.

If the court looks at the entire picture, it is clear that Armstrong could not have brought suit prior to the time he left Scientology in December 1981, and that his cause of action is therefore not barred by the three year statute.

A. THE ALLEGATIONS REGARDING CONFIDENTIALITY OF AUDITING INFORMATION ARE NOT BARRED BY THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.

Cross-defendant’s argument is based solely on Armstrong’s “admissions against interest” as contained in his answers to interrogatories served in 1983 (See Exhibit “A” to Motion, Interrogatory No. 16.)

Although Armstrong discovered, while he was in the organization, that auditing folders were culled for “crimes,” he was mentally incapable of taking any action.

-2-

Cross-defendant omits from its citation of Armstrong’s answers to interrogatories (See Exhibit “A” to Motion), those portions of his answers wherein he describes his broken will, his inability to control his own life, his complete manipulation by the Organization, his feelings of terror and the system of control and deprivation that was exerted over him. (See Declaration of Gerald Armstrong filed herewith, p. 9-12, paragraph 8- 9.)

At that time and until he left the Organization in 1981, Armstrong was wholly incapable of action against the organization for a number of reasons.

First, as a member of Scientology, Armstrong was made to sign waivers, non-disclosure and release bonds, as well as staff contracts containing promises to forbear from litigation. Attached hereto as Exhibit [M] is a Nondisclosure and Release bond signed by Armstrong on March 18, 1977. At page 2 of Exhibit “M” it states:

“. . . he/she (Obligor) will never disclose any information, data, or knowledge he/she has or will learn about the organization of the church, or any of the church’s affiliated churches, missions, or organizations, including but not limited to their internal structures, functions or activities, and certain information which may be

-3-

orally imparted to the Obligor in the course of his/her having been a staff member of the Church.” In the event of a disclosure, the obligor promises to pay $10,000 to “the Church.”

At trial of the complainant in this case, Armstrong testified that he was ordered to sign several of such documents while he was in the RPF (Rehabilitation Project Force – the Scientology prison). At the time, he was under a form of mind control sufficient to make him sign virtually any document. Although the document was not explained to him, he had heard that he would be obligated to pay $10,000 if he disclosed any information, data or knowledge about Scientology. (A copy of said trial testimony of May 10, 1984, p. 1465-1466 is attached hereto as Exhibit [N]).

Second, as explained by Armstrong in his answers to interrogatories, he was in the RPF from July 1, 1976 to
December 1, 1977, where he was “humiliated, degraded, terrorized and defrauded” to the extent that he “lost self respect and rationality.” (See Exhibit “A” to Motion, p. 23).

It was during the years 1976 and 1977 that Armstrong was forced to participate in culling of auditing folders. However, because of his fear of reprisal, his desire to believe in the good of the Organization, his total manipulation by the system of reporting “overts” or critical thoughts, and his understanding that he was responsible for

-4-

payment of $10,000 as the result of a disclosure, Armstrong was incapable of action. This incapability was the direct result of the action and policies of cross-defendant.

The organization adhered to a strict system of “ethics” and punishment. This is evidenced by a number of
Hubbard’s policies, one of which is particularly applicable here.

Policy Letter of 23 December 1965 entitled Suppressive Acts; Suppression of Scientology and Scientologists; The Fair Game Law, lists various “suppressive” acts for which an individual becomes “Fair Game.” Among those are:

“. . . testifying hostilely before state or public inquiries into Scientology. . . reporting or threatening to report Scientology or Scientologists to civil authorities . . . bringing civil suit against any Scientology organization or Scientologist . . . testifying as a hostile witness against Scientology in public.” (A copy of said Policy Letter is attached hereto as Exhibit “O.” See p. 553.)

Armstrong was aware of this policy, and it added to his fear that the organization would use Fair Game for any his fear that the organization would use Fair Game for any

-5-

activity involving litigation. Direct evidence that Scientology practiced its Fair Game policy against litigants and critics, is shown by the treatment to which Armstrong was and is subjected since the filing of his cross-complaint.

Third, in staff contracts which Scientology members are forced to sign, the organization routinely includes the following language:

“. . . I recognize, understand and agree that in consideration for the Church permitting me to become an active participant pursuant to this declaration, I shall not commence any action or assert any claim against either or both of them (L. Ron Hubbard or Mary Sue Hubbard), their heirs, successors, or assigns, based on any matter arising out of or in connection with the Church . . .” (See Declaration of Religious Commitment and Application for Active Participation on Church Staff, attached hereto as Exhibit [P], p. 3.)

There is no question but that the intimidation tactics used by the Organization to control and manipulate

-6-

activity involving litigation. Direct evidence that Scientology practiced its Fair Game policy against litigants and critics, is shown by the treatment to which Armstrong was and is subjected since the filing of his cross complaint.

Third, in staff contracts which Scientology members are forced to sign, the organization routinely includes the following language:

“. . . I recognize, understand and agree that in consideration for the Church permitting me to become an active participant pursuant to this declaration, I shall not commence any action or assert any claim against either or both of them (L. Ron Hubbard or Mary Sue Hubbard), their heirs, successors, or assigns, based on any matter arising out of or in connection with the Church . . .” (See Declaration of Religious Commitment and Application for Active Participation on Church Staff, attached hereto as [P] , p. 3.)

There is no question but that the intimidation tactics used by the Organization to control and manipulate

-7-

members include the representations that one cannot sue the Organization or the Hubbards for fear of the Fair Game doctrine. It is in this climate and pursuant to these policies that Armstrong became mindless,  following the directives and orders of superiors, incapable of rational choice.

Mind control was the basis for reversal of the dismissal of a complaint for personal injury on statute of limitations grounds in Roney v Siri Singh Sahib Harbhajan Singh Yogi, 103 N.M. 89, 703 P.2d 186 (1985) (A copy of the opinion is attached as Exhibit [Q].)

Roney involved a woman who, as a member of the Sikh Dharma Brotherhood, underwent a tubal ligation rendering her sterile. She was told that her problems were centered on her ovaries which had to be removed. It was not until a year and a half after she left the Sikhs that she regained her “free will and comprehension” allowing her to file suit.

Id. at 188. By that time, the three year statute of limitations had expired. In reversing the trial court’s dismissal of the complaint, the Court of Appeals of New Mexico held:

“Because she alleges that the continuation of her ‘lack of free will and comprehension’ was a direct and proximate result of defendants’ mind and body control techniques, she is, in effect, also alleging

-7-

that she could not have reasonably known her cause of action within the statutory period.” Id. at 188.

Although Roney was venued in New Mexico, Armstrong cites it here because of the striking analogy to the circumstances of his mind control by Scientology. Like the plaintiff in Roney, Armstrong did not  reasonably” know his causes of action until he left the Organization in 1981 because he was bereft of his free will. Until then, he labored under the false representations and mind control tactics of cross-defendant and Hubbard, incapable of rational thought.

His failure to act upon his causes of action is a direct result of the intimidating, harassive and wrongful conduct he underwent while a member of cross-defendant. Cross-Defendant should not now be allowed to assert the statute of limitations bar where the delay in filing suit was a direct result of cross-defendant’s  intimidation and manipulation of Armstrong.

In that regard, although cross-defendant argues that Armstrong should have investigated the misrepresentations with respect to the confidentiality of auditing, it was cross-defendant who prevented Armstrong from doing so through the conduct outlined above and described more fully, infra, under subsection B.

Thus, the case of Miller v. Bechtel Corp. (1983) 33 Cal.3d 868, 191 Cal.Rptr. 619 cited by cross-defendant is

-8-

not applicable. In Miller, plaintiff failed to investigate her cause of action where she had every opportunity to do so and was in contact with her attorney. Clearly, the circumstances of this case are far from what occurred in Miller.

B. CROSS-DEFENDANT MUST BE ESTOPPED FROM ASSERTING A STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS DEFENSE IN THAT CROSS-DEFENDANT INDUCED THE DELAY THROUGH ITS OWN WRONGFUL CONDUCT.

As set forth in Armstrong’s answer to Interrogatory No., propounded by cross-defendant, Armstrong lived under tremendous intimidation tactics designed to destroy his will. 16 (See Exhibit “A” to motion, pp. 21-30.) In 1976, he was locked up and maintained under guard for three weeks by the G.O., during which time he was forced to write up lists of his “crimes”. He was then sent to the RPF in 1976 where he remained for seventeen months. In the RPF he was humiliated, degraded and terrorized by being treated like a criminal and denied access to all outside contact. He was forced to work for long hours without sufficient rest or sleep.

Armstrong saw those who asked to leave the RPF locked up and abused, forced to sign lists of “crimes”. He also signed a number of non-disclosure and release bonds promising not to divulge activities of Scientology. In 1978, Armstrong was again assigned to the RPF, where he remained through the spring of 1979. During this time, he was forced to do manual labor for sixteen hours per

-9-

day over several months and was paid less than $9.00 per week. Armstrong slept in cramped conditions and ate only leftover food. He was punished, deprived of contact with the outside world and completely manipulated and controlled.

It was in this atmosphere that Armstrong was forced to participate in the culling of auditing folders and forced to allow his own folders to be culled.

Based upon the harsh treatment and punishments meted out for “crimes,” based upon the non-disclosure and release bonds he signed and based upon the written policies of the Organization dealing with suppressive persons, Armstrong could not act as a reasonable person. His will had been broken and his rational thought gone.

It was not until 1981, when he began reviewing voluminous documents on the life of Hubbard that he slowly came to his senses, culminating in his departure from Scientology in December 1981.

As a result of the threats, physical and emotional abuse, and intimidation incurred by  Armstrong at the hands of cross-defendant, he was prevented from bringing suit. Clear issues and questions of fact arise which would make summary judgment inappropriate.

California case law supports the proposition that a defendant may be estopped to plead the statute of limitations where the defendant induced the plaintiff by fraud, misrepresentations or deception from filing a timely action. Moss v. Underwriters Report (1938) 12 Ca1.2d 266, 83 P.2d 503. The estoppel doctrine is one founded in equity where

-10-

it is stated that “no man may take advantage of his own wrong.” Glus v. Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (1979) 359 U.S. 231, 3 L.Ed. 2d 770, 79 S.Ct. 760. The court in Glus further observed that the principle of estoppel has been applied in many cases of both law and equity to bar an inequitable reliance on the statute of limitation.

The purpose of the statute of limitations is to provide repose and protect persons against the burden of having to defend against stale claims. Wyatt v. Union Mortgage Co. (1979) 157 Ca1.Rptr. 392, 598 P.2d 45. Here there is no need to protect the cross-defendant since it is the very culprit who fraudulently induced Armstrong from bringing suit. Moreover, the threats and intimidations continued even after Armstrong left the Organization when it labelled Armstrong a “Suppressive Person” and sent private investigators to his house to harass him and his wife, when it surreptitiously and unlawfully videotaped him in 1984 and when it continued to reveal portions of his auditing files, among other things.

In Wyatt, supra, the court held that:

“Just as the statute of limitations does not run against an action based on fraud so long as fraud remains concealed, so ought the statute to be tolled even after fraud is discovered, for so long as sheer economic duress or undue influence

-11-

embedded in fraud continues to hold the victim in place.”

It is clear from Armstrong’s declaration and answers to interrogatories that the fear and harassment continues to date and is heightened by the fact that cross-defendant has made blatant “revelations” from Armstrong’s auditing folders, failing to advise the court that the majority of the “revelations” never occurred. This has caused Armstrong extreme emotional distress.

Armstrong has established sufficient facts to show that he was prevented from filing suit in this case because of intimidating, threatening and coercive behavior of the cross-defendant. Thus cross-defendant should be barred from now taking advantage of its tortious conduct:

“A plaintiff’s right to relief in cases of fraud and deceit is not dependent upon technical legal definitions. The defendant, having by fraud and deceit concealed material facts and by misrepresentations hindered the plaintiff from bringing an action within the statutory period is estopped from taking advantage of his own wrong.

The statute of limitations was intended as a shield for the

-12-

defendant’s protection against stale claims, but he may not use it to perpetuate a fraud upon a diligent plaintiff.” Pashley v. Pacific Electric Co. (1944) 25 Ca1.2d 226,153 P.2d 325.

C. CROSS-DEFENDANT CONTINUES TO VIOLATE ITS REPRESENTATION THAT AUDITING FILES ARE CONFIDENTIAL.

In the face of strenuous arguments made over the past four years in this case that auding files are confidential, cross-defendant allowed its attorneys to review, copy and index Armstrong’s auditing files. Cross-Defendant also filed a document with the court wherein cross-defendant allegedly cites incidents taken from the folders. (Armstrong declaration, pp. 1-2, paragraphs 3-4.)

Armstrong asked for the folders through discovery to see whether they had been culled as he believes they were. He did not ask for them so the contents could be published by cross-defendant. There is no question that his folders contain personal information. However, in its own twisted way, cross-defendant, the “protector” of auditing “sanctity,” has taken the liberty of allegedly revealing portions of the folders in a court filing. (Armstrong declaration, pp. 5-7, paragraph 6.)

Another example of this continuing fraud is found in the admissions contained in the B-1 materials produced by

-13-

cross-defendant. The B-1 file shows conclusively that Armstrong’s auditing folders were culled after he left the Organization in 1981. Armstrong did not learn of this culling until the B-1 materials were made available to him in 1985 during his testimony in the Christofferson case. (Armstrong declaration, p. 7-9, paragraph 7.)

Armstrong never knew of the existence of B-1 files kept on individuals while he was in Scientology. (See Exhibit “A” to Motion, p. 29, lines 17-20.) He also had no knowledge of the existence of GO 121669, the policy regarding culling of auditing files (See Exhibit “A” to motion, p. 9, lines 14-19). He discovered these matters only after he left the Organization in 1981.

Scientology continued its fraudulent conduct toward him after he left as evidenced by the  information contained in his B-1 file and in the court filing of alleged excerpts from his auditing folder.

As long as cross-defendant continues to commit such wrongful acts against Armstrong, his causes of action for fraud, emotional distress, and breach of contract will not accrue. Wyatt v. Union Mortgage Co. (1979) 24 Cal.3d 773, 157 Cal.Rptr. 392, 598 P.2d 45.

D. THE FRAUD CAUSE OF ACTION CONTAINS NO ALLEGATIONS OF “RELIGIOUS STATUS”

Cross-defendant argues that Armstrong was “aware” of the “Church’s scientific, non-religious status by September, 1975.” This argument makes no sense in that

-14-

Armstrong has never alleged that Scientology was a religion. To the contrary, Armstrong has alleged that  Scientology held itself out as a scientifically guaranteed process, designed to cure all the ills and problems known to man. It is this representation which Armstrong believes is fraudulent. The testimony cited by cross-defendant in its Motion coincides with Armstrong’s allegations. (See Motion, p. 13.) Armstrong testified that he joined Scientology on the basis of the representation that Scientology was the “science of knowing how to know,” and not on the basis of any representation that it was a religion. In fact, his testimony clearly states that the “religious” cloak of Scientology was just a “cover.” Thus, cross-defendant’s arguments make no sense.

E. THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS DOES NOT BAR ALLEGATIONS REGARDING THE BENEFITS OF AUDITING BECAUSE THE MISREPRESENTATIONS WERE CONTINUING IN NATURE.

Once again, cross-defendant tells only part of the story when it argues that Armstrong had doubts as to the “workability” of Scientology in November 1969.

Pursuant to the Declaration of Gerald Armstrong filed herewith, cross-defendant used a “bait and switch” approach when making representations regarding the benefits of auditing. (Armstrong Declaration, p. 14, ln. 5-16.)

When Armstrong felt the auditing he was receiving did not resolve problems, he was told that the resolution would

-15-

occur at the level of “Clear.” When it did not occur at the level of “Clear,” he was told it would occur at the level of “OT III.”

That is the typical tactic used by cross-defendant to maintain control over and manipulate the will of members. It is the proverbial “dangling carrot” that will be reached with just a little more auditing and money.

Of course, it must be kept in mind that Armstrong was always laboring under fear of reprisal or punishment for any “overt” or critical thought regarding Scientology, the Scientology process or the Hubbards. Thus, he was incapable of investigating the “unworkability” of auditing.

It was only until a stroke of good fortune befell him and he became Hubbard Archivist that he was slowly able to piece together a picture of a fraud so massive that it brought him back to rational thought and compelled him to leave Scientology. He could never have performed this investigation without the permission given to him by L. Ron Hubbard following Armstrong’s discovery of archive documents.

Clearly, questions of fact exist as to the “bait and switch” techniques used by cross-defendant to force individuals into continuing the auditing process. Additional questions of fact exist as to the system of  ethics and punishment used by cross-defendant to drive members into submission, taking from them their free and rational thought.

///

-16-

II

THE SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION FOR INTENTIONAL INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS IS NOT PARTIALLY BARRED BY THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS

Cross-Defendant makes the same argument as to the second cause of action that it set forth with respect to the first cause of action for fraud. Cross-Defendant seeks to bar those allegations of the second cause of action regarding the violation of auditing confidentiality allegedly known to Armstrong by 1977.

Armstrong thus incorporates by reference all of the arguments made under Section I of this opposition, supra.

III

THE FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT IS NOT PARTIALLY  BARRED BY THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS

Again, cross-defendant makes the same argument as contained under the arguments for the first cause of action for fraud. Cross-Defendant seeks summary adjudication as to the allegations regarding the benefits of auditing, the status of Scientology and the confidentiality of auditing folders.

-17-

Armstrong thus incorporates by reference all of the arguments made under Section I of this opposition, supra.

IV

CONCLUSION

Based upon the foregoing, it is respectfully submitted that numerous questions of fact exist as to the treatment of Armstrong by the Organization in the form of punishment, intimidation, threats and  harassment; the resulting state of Armstrong’s mind and his inability to function as a reasonably prudent or rational person; the written policies of the organization linking suppressive acts to litigation and the resulting punishments therefor; the effect of the non-disclosure and release bonds as well as the arguments to forbear from litigation; and the general attitude of cross-defendant to anyone slightly critical of Scientology or Hubbard to have committed “crimes” and “overts,” with its attendant effect on Armstrong and his inability to file suit.

Additionally, there are the continuing acts of cross-defendant in violating the confidentiality of auditing folders which it has so vehemently maintained are sacrosanct, and the continuing tortious conduct of cross-defendant in harassing Armstrong and intentionally causing him emotional distress.

///
///

-18-

It is thus respectfully requested that the motion for summary adjudication be denied.

DATED: November 5 , 1986 CONTOS & BUNCH
By: [signed]
JULIA DRAGOJEVIC
Attorneys for Defendant
and Cross-Complainant
GERALD ARMSTRONG

-19-

Exhibit [M] Non-disclosure and Release Bond [.pdf]

Exhibit [N] Transcript re Bond May 10, 1984

Exhibit [P] Cult Employee Contract [.pdf]

Exhibit [Q] 103 N.M. 89, 703 P.2d 186 (1985) [.pdf]

Filed Under: Armstrong 1 Tagged With: By: Julia Dragojevic Esq., Case No. C 420153, Declaration, Opposition, PC Files, Points and Authorities, Priest-Penitent Privilege

CT 6411-6426: Declaration Of Gerald Armstrong (November 1, 1986)

November 1, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: Gerald Armstrong
View/Download: CT 6411-6426: Declaration Of Gerald Armstrong (November 1, 1986)
Exhibit to: EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF 20TH CAUSE OF ACTION; AND 13TH, 16TH, 17TH & 19TH CAUSES OF ACTION OF SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT VOLUME II (September 18, 1995)

 

Filed Under: Armstrong 4 Record on Appeal Tagged With: Armstrong 4 Record On Appeal Exhibit, By: Gerald Armstrong, Declaration, Gerald Armstrong Declaration

DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 1, 1986)

November 1, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: Gerald Armstrong
View/Download: DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 1, 1986)
View/Download: DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 1, 1986) (Exhibits)
Exhibit to: OPPOSITION OF CROSS-COMPLAINANT GERALD ARMSTRONG TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF ISSUES; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT THEREOF; DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 5, 1986)

 

I, Gerald Armstrong, declare:

1. I am making this declaration in support of an opposition to plaintiff organization’s motion for summary adjudication.

2. The organization’s motion deals with a serious issue, one which affects the life of potentially thousands of individuals, and one which has become for me emotionally devastating and mind-altering, in a manner which is illogical and perverse. The realization that the people behind this
motion and behind all the pc file violations; that is, the attorneys and the few who control organization money, will stop at nothing, no lie, or perversion of reality, no act, to, as Hubbard ordered, ruin me utterly, has some time ago gone far beyond a passing thought.

3. Mr. Peterson’s argument in the summary adjudication motion is that “by 1978 (I) knew, or reasonably should have known” about the violations of my pc files, and that because my cross-complaint was filed in September 1982; my causes of action for fraud, intentional infliction of emotional distress and breach of contract as they relate to the organization’s violations of my pc files are barred by applicable statutes of limitation. Mr. Peterson twists what I knew in 1978 with what I knew in the fall of 1981 and what I learned subsequently. The

-1-

whole statute of limitations argument is rendered ludicrous, however, by the fact that the organization and its attorneys have continued both the fraud of promised sanctity of pc files and violation thereof right up to the present time. Attached hereto as Exhibit [A] is a copy of the organization’s “objection to release of preclear files “dated July 3, 1986 filed with this Court. At p. 2 of this document, organization attorney Donald Randolph states: “only within the last few weeks have these files been copied, indexed and reviewed by counsel.” Mr. Randolph included in the “objection” several pages of statements he gloats were culled from my pc files. I have blacked out these statements in the document copy attached.

4. Attached hereto as Exhibit [B] is a copy of a declaration dated December 18, 1983 which I wrote to support a motion to get my pc files delivered to me. At p. 8 I state, “I do not waive the (priest-penitent) privilege, and in fact I insist upon it.” In a demonstration of the organization’s malevolent intent, Mr. Randolph asks this Court a p. 5 of the ” objection” to “require Armstrong and his counsel to provide a waiver of the priest-penitent privilege.” To veil the organization’s antisocial acts with an illusion of legitimacy, Mr. Randolph states at p. 6 of the “objection” that if I even obtain copies of my pc files (part of which I do now have) the organization “will be forced against its wishes, to utilize the same documentation in its defense as evidence of Armstrong’s character and perjurious statements.” This is blackmail. And it is the clearest proof of the sanctity fraud, the

-2-

organization’s actual policy regarding use of “confidential” pc file information against the pc, and the basic fraud of Hubbard and his creation.

5. Attached hereto as Exhibit [C] is a declaration dated July 14, 1985 written by Frank K. Flinn, B.D., Ph.D.,  the organization’s “religious expert.” This declaration was filed in this case along with the organization’s “response,” of July 30, 1985 to the Court’s July 2, 1985 Discovery Order. At pp. 18-20, Dr. Flinn compares Scientology’s policies and practices regarding the “sanctity” of pre-clear files with those of other “religions.”

“Another religious practice of the Church of Scientology which has come under scrutiny is the  issue of the confidentiality exercised with respect to the auditing records of members and  specially of the “pre-clear files” of upper-level church members. I find the practice of the Church of Scientology in this regard fully in keeping with the practices of other religions. In general, there are two fundamental reasons why churches, including the Church of Scientology, seek confidentiality with regard to unauthorized examination of spiritual records. The first is to preserve the sanctity of the spiritual privacy of the believer. ….

-3-

In regard to the first reason, the spiritual privacy of the believer, Scientology is like every  religion known to me. The Roman Catholic Church protects the priest-penitent relationship with the severest of sanctions, including dismissal from priestly office and expulsion from the Church itself. Upon ordination priests take an oath of the “confessional seal” before they are allowed to hear the confession of sins and administer official spiritual counselling. My pastor, a Monsignor in the Roman Catholic Church, has testified to me that he would undergo  imprisonment and death before revealing the contents of any confession, whether this revelation was demanded by the President of the United States or by the Pope of Rome. ….

Abuse of the archive and unauthorized divulging of information can bring severe penalties, including demotion from office, penances and even excommunication.

Most Protestant denominations have similar regulations and penalties in their respective church polities.

Likewise Scientology has codes of conduct for auditors and other officials regarding authorized files. The Church does not allow any outsider access to a parishioner’s files as a matter of  priest-pentient privilege, as is the case with other churches. Confidentiality of this type of material touches on the nerve center of religion itself. The historical record

-4-

shows that no church lightly suffers the intrusion into such records by the government or any other outside agency. The history of the Reign of Terror in France reveals the great number of priests who went to the guillotine rather than break the confessional seal.”

Neither the President, the Pope, this Court nor anyone other than the organizations’ leaders and attorneys ordered the violations of the “sanctity” of my pc files. These leaders and the attorneys reveal a radically different standard of conduct and ethics from that of the ministers of “other religions” who went to the guillotine rather than divulge the confessions of their preclears.

6. Attached hereto as Exhibit [D] is a declaration signed by Reverend Ken Hoden, “president” of one of the new “corporations” “divested” recently by the ” California” organization. This declaration was also filed in this case with the ” response” to the July 2, 1985 Discovery Order.

Mr. Hoden states at par. 3:

“Materials and information stored or recorded within the confessional folders (PC folders) are confidential and privileged. Our religious doctrine prohibits any parishioner or person receiving pastoral counselling (auditing) from viewing the contents of their folders. Our religious doctrines also prohibit any external dissemination of preclear folders. Even our attorneys

-5-

are forbidden to review these folders. The only people who are allowed to view the pastoral  counselling folders are authorized Church ministers.

Yet, my pc files were given to attorneys, culled and used against me. Mr. Randolph even defines the statements he culled from my “confidential” pc files “as admissions against Armstrong’s interest.” It is clear that the defense the organization’s attorneys have desperately devised to their inhuman and criminal actions is the threatened divulgence of the materials culled from my pc files and my resultant hoped and worked for emotional disintegration. The filing of the culled statements ” under seal” is a cheap attempt to give an  appearance of morality to the organization’s perfidious act. Dozens of organization attorneys, staff members, and attorney staff have seen the culled statements. They were placed in front of the Judge in this case, the individual who can most affect the outcome of this case and the rest of my life. Several of the incidents ” culled” from my pc files as “admissions” never happened. Mr. Randolph and whoever helped him, in their ignorance of auditing and recklessness , have apparently culled imaginary ” past life” incidents or have created the incidents out of whole cloth. For several other incidents, Mr. Randolph’s interpretation is twisted beyond recognition. When he states at p. 2 that ” the Church still maintains that the sanctity of the confessional must be placed above all other concerns,” he lays to rest Mr. Peterson’s statute of limitations argument because he shows that the fraud is continuing. The organization is still claiming out of one side of its mouth that

-6-

the sanctity of pc files is its paramount concern while out the other side it spits its victims’ innermost thoughts and secrets and when these treacherously obtained and used thoughts and secrets are not sufficiently juicy to achieve the organization’s black PR ends, it has someone fabricate them.

7. At p. 8 of the summary adjudication motion Mr. Peterson states:

“The only way Armstrong can avoid the bar of the statute of limitations is by proving that he did not and could not have discovered the events alleged in his Cross Complaint any earlier than he did.”

As has already been shown the culling of my files admitted to by the organization occurred in 1986 and I only learned of this fact in July this year, almost four years after the filing of the cross-complaint. Attached hereto as Exhibit [E] is a page from what the organization produced as my “B-1 time track.” The entry at April 7, 1980 is taken from my pc files (in session). I only learned of this culling in March 1985 when the organization produced some B-1 materials in the Christofferson case in Oregon. Even using the organization’s date for the culled incident of April 7, 1980, this is two years after the 1978 date Mr. Peterson would like the Court to use. And when I learned of this culling is two and half years after the filing of the cross-complaint. Attached hereto as Exhibit [F] is a document entitled “Gerry Armstrong Project” dated February 17, 1982. Step 2 reads:

“Go through his files and folders to extract the names

-7-

of people who knew him and who are still well connected up and completely trustworthy.  Interview these people to find out who Gerry’s close friends were and to see if he had any relatives in this area (we could then follow up to see if he might be staying with them).

This is the use of my pc files for intelligence data to be used against me. Attached hereto as Exhibit [G] is a “daily report dated February 22, 1982, from Assistant Guardian for Intelligence (AGI), Brad Ballentine to his organizational seniors at GOUS. He states in the fourth paragraph:

“SU (Special Unit, the name for the Gilman Hotspring compound) and Flag (the Clearwater, Florida base) have sent us all their files on him (Armstrong).”

“Us” is the GO intelligence bureau. I only learned of this transmission of my pc files to the organization’s intelligence bureau and this use to which they were then put in March 1985, again two and half years after the filing of the cross-complaint. Attached hereto as Exhibit [H] is a declaration dated May 7, 1985 written by me in support of efforts to obtain my pc files from the organization, and prevent its continued violations of them. In paragraphs 5 through 9 I describe an organization intelligence operation involving the use of my pc files to entrap me. Much of the operation occurred in 1984, some six years after Mr. Peterson claims I should have known about it. I only became aware of the operation in April 1985 when organization attorneys used its product to attack me in the Christofferson case. It’s perhaps unfortunate for the organization that it gave my pc file the intelligence bureau

-8-

for culling and intelligence purposes in 1982, used them to set up the illegal videotaping of me in 1984, and again culled my files to concoct the “objection to release of preclear files” in 1986, since in so doing it lost any shot it may have had at obtaining a summary adjudication based on the statutes of limitations. The organization’s misfortune cannot begin, however, to compare with the pain and anguish it subjected me to with these acts. If the organization had acted decently, and not violated either overtly or covertly, my pc files, the situation today might be quite different.

8.Even without considering the pc file violations after I left the organization in 1981 or even back into the 1970’s, the summary adjudication motion still falls because I had been rendered by the organization and Hubbard, until I began to come to my senses in late 1981, something different from “a reasonably prudent person.” Mr. Peterson has selected statements from some of my response to interrogatories as “admissions against (my) own interest” to show that I learned of the culling in the 1970’s while in the organization. From the same responses used by Mr. Peterson, attached to his motion as Exhibit A, I have excerpted the following three statements by me which show why a reasonably

///

-9-

prudent person perceiving the same tip of the pc file violation iceberg that I did in the 1970s would or  should have fled in disgust and filed suit for the fraud and related crimes and torts, and why I could not.

P.6 “In 1976 while locked up and guarded by the Guardian’s Office on the orders of L. Ron  Hubbard, I was told that my auditing reports were being gone through by GO staff. Had I protested this action, I would have remained locked up indefinitely. I had no control of my preclear folders, nor any control of those who had access to them. My will was broken by this time, and I was effectively controlled and manipulated by L. Ron Hubbard and the organization.

In 1976 through through December of 1977, I was assigned to and kept on the RPF by L. Ron Hubbard and those under his control. A system of control and deprivation was exerted over me throughout this period and a campaign of harassment and terror was directed against me and the RPF as ordered by Hubbard.

….

P.9 “If I had known of the existence of this policy (GO 121669) and the practice of disclosure of ” confidential” session information, I would never have become involved with Scientology. I was brought along as far as I went with the organization by the systematic trickery and manipulation by L. Ron Hubbard and the organization.

….

-10-

P.23 “I spent from July 1, 1976 to December 1, 1977 on the RPF on Hubbard’s order. I was  humiliated, degraded, terrorized and defrauded by Hubbard during this period. I underwent tremendous emotional trauma and lost self respect and rationality.

The proof of the mind manipulation run by Hubbard and the organization is that I stayed so long after so much degradation and betrayal. Only in late 1981 when I spotted Hubbard as the source of the fraud and the organization’s antisocial conduct, and after leaving the organization when the control mechanisms began to fall away,did I become aware of the criminal significance of pc file culling and the fraud which makes it possible.

9. Hubbard also used the auditing process itself, by which he claimed to be freeing people, to subtly program them to not even think a critical thought about the deplorable conditions in which they were kept, including a questioning of auditing or the pc file violations which might be observed or heard about. During any auditing session, if the preclear makes any critical comment, the auditor will immediately demand of the preclear any “overt”, that is any misdeed, crime or intentionally harmful act, he has committed. In Hubbard’s system, any criticism meant that the person making it had a hidden undisclosed crime. One of his bulletins, ” Session Must-nots,” attached hereto as Exhibit [I], states this point:

“When a pc is critical of the auditor, the organization or any of the many things in life, this is always a symptom of overts priorly committed by the pc.

-11-

….

This is a sweeping fully embracive statement – and a true one. There are no criticisms in the absence of overts committed earlier by the pc.

Very soon after some auditing in the Sea Organization I learned that any criticism I had meant I had done something bad, and after a while I even was stopped from thinking any thought critical of Hubbard or the organization. In Hubbard’s dictionary of Scientology terms, a “critical thought” in fact is defined as “a symptom of an overt act having been committed.” The page from the dictionary is attached hereto as Exhibit [J]. This concept, although programmed into people in auditing, pervaded every part or aspect of the organization. So the criticisms of a staff member about Hubbard’s or the GO’s practices, and specifically pc file violations, were not listened to; rather he would be investigated or sec checked for his “crimes.” By contrast, however, it could never be thought that Hubbard, who was constantly critical of doctors, judges, scientists, psychologists, government, teachers, and especially Scientologists and Sea Org members, had himself committed crimes or overts, because such a thought about him was clearly “critical.” Thus he achieved almost absolute mind control.

10. Beginning at page 10 of the summary adjudication motion, Mr. Peterson makes a confusing argument that:

“Armstrong is barred by Statute of Limitations from asserting Scientology’s religious status, and auditing benefits as “misrepresentations” as Armstrong had a

-12-

duty to investigate these “facts” more than 3 years prior to date of cross-complaint.

Mr. Peterson further states at p. 14:

“Clearly, if Armstrong is to be believed, he was aware of what he terms the scientific  non-religious nature of Scientology no later than 1975.

How that helps the organization’s position is baffling. It is the basis of the whole Hubbardian fraud. It was Hubbard’s scientific guarantees for auditing and Scientology which were the lure into the organization. Even the promise of auditing confidentiality was given in scientific terms and differentiated from ” religious confessions” which Hubbard claimed had degenerated into “a kind of blackmail.” In his bulletin of January 21, 1960, attached hereto as Exhibit [K] he stated:

“Some churches used a mechanism of confession. This was a limited effort to relieve a person  of his overt acts. Later the mechanism of confession was employed as a kind of blackmail by which increased contribution could be obtained from the person confessing. Factually this is a limited mechanism to such an extent that it can be extremely dangerous. Religious confession does not carry with it any real stress of responsibility for the individual but on the contrary seeks to lay responsibility at the door of the Divinity — a sort of blasphemy in itself. I have no axe to grind here with religion. Religion as religion is fairly natural. But psychotherapy must be in itself a completed fact or, as we all know, it can become a dangerous fact.

-13-

Hubbard goes on in the same bulletin to ask auditors to “make your pc write these overts and withholds down and sign them and send them off to me.” His motivation for this policy is not altruistic, and it only became clear to me in 1981. The other part of Mr. Peterson’s argument is that since I had some doubts in my early Scientology years I had a duty from that point to investigate. Mr. Peterson includes in the testimony from the trial in the underlying case, however, at p. 15 of the motion my statement of what happened when I did question the fact that the auditing I had had did not resolve what I considered the essential problem: “I was told after doing the auditing steps that that would only happen at Clear.” And “clear” only happened around 1979, and that did not produce the promised results of auditing, but I was told these would happen at another “higher level” called OT III. In other words an aspect of the continuing fraud was bait and switch.

Attached hereto as Exhibit [L] is a policy written by Hubbard dated February 25, 1966 entitled Attacks on Scientology” wherein he orders:

“NEVER agree to an investigation of Scientology. ONLY agree to an investigation of the attackers.”

The investigation Mr. Peterson is seeking to convince the Court I had a duty to make was impossible. In fact I did something of an investigation in 1980 and 1981 when it was somewhat possible and the results of the investigation were a major factor in my leaving the organization and Hubbard.

11. Mr. Peterson claims at p. 16 of the motion that the intentional infliction of emotional distress cause of action is

-14-

barred by the statute of limitations in regards to the pc file violations since I was emotionally distressed in 1976 and 1977 while I was locked up, in the RPF, and generally being manipulated and degraded on a daily basis by the organization on Hubbard’s orders. Mr. Peterson’s argument is hollow since culling or my files occurred as well, as has been shown above, in the 1980s and as recently as July this year. The emotional  distress I have experienced from the 1986 culling alone is beyond description. Mr. Peterson’s argument that I am barred by the statute of limitations because of my knowledge in the 1970s that pc file culling occurred is like telling a victim of years of abuse that he or she cannot do anything about it because the abuse has gone on so long.

Interrogatory no. 16, the response to which Mr. Peterson has quoted from at p. 17, states:

“With regard to the second cause of action of your first amended cross-complaint for damages for alleged intentional infliction of emotional distress against cross-defendants Scientology and Hubbard, to the extent you have not done so, in response to the above interrogatory, provide the following factual basis for such cause of action:

A. The specific and full factual basis–for all the allegations contained in said cause of action.

Mr. Peterson’s assumption that the date that I “first suffered severe emotional distress as a consequence” of realizing the organization had and would my innermost thoughts and secrets, was “by 1978″ is erroneous. And the conclusion, at p. 18 of the

-15-

motion, that “Armstrong had knowledge of what he contends were all the above referenced breaches of the so-called contract no later than December 1, 1977,” and at p. 8 that “(i)n reality, Armstrong has not testified that he knew anything in the Fall of 1981 that he had not already known as of 1978, by the latest”omit any reference to and attempt to slip by the whole biography project, Hubbard’s archives and the underlying case which the organization brought.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.

Executed this first day of November, 1986 at Boston, Massachusetts.

[signed]
Gerald Armstrong

-16-

Exhibit [A] Objection Of Cross-Defendant Church of Scientology To Release Preclear Files 07-03-1986

Exhibit [B] Armstrong Declaration 12-18-1983

Exhibit [C] Declaration of Frank K. Flinn 07-14-1985

Exhibit [D] Declaration of Ken Hoden 07-29-1985 [.pdf]

Exhibit [E] Page from B1’s “time-track” on Armstrong

B1 Time Track (partial) [ .pdf]

 

Exhibit [F] “The Gerry Armstrong Project ”

Exhibit [G] AGI “Daily report” 02-22-1982

Exhibit [H] Armstrong Declaration 05-07-1985

Exhibit [I] HCO Bulletin 24 August 1964 SESSION MUST-NOTS © 1964 L. Ron Hubbard

Exhibit [J] Dianetics and Scientology Technical Dictionary — definition ” critical thought” © L. Ron Hubbard

Exhibit [K] HCO Bulletin 21 January AD10 [1960] JUSTIFICATION © 1960 L. Ron Hubbard

Exhibit [L] HCO Policy Letter 25 Feburary 1966 ATTACKS ON SCIENTOLOGY © 1966 L. Ron Hubbard

Filed Under: Armstrong 1 Tagged With: By: Gerald Armstrong, Case No. C 420153, Declaration, Gerald Armstrong Declaration, Priest-Penitent Privilege

DECLARATION OF JOHN G. PETERSON IN RESPONSE TO CROSS-COMPLAINANT’S OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSIONS TO TAKE DEPOSITIONS OUTSIDE CALIFORNIA AND MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF LETTERS ROGATORY AND IN RESPONSE TO DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (Partial) (October 20, 1986)

October 20, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: John G. Peterson, Esq.
View/Download: DECLARATION OF JOHN G. PETERSON IN RESPONSE TO CROSS-COMPLAINANT'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSIONS TO TAKE DEPOSITIONS OUTSIDE CALIFORNIA AND MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF LETTERS ROGATORY AND IN RESPONSE TO DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (Partial) (October 20, 1986)
Exhibit to: DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (November 7, 1986)

 

Filed Under: Armstrong 1 Tagged With: By: John G. Peterson Esq., Case No. C 420153, Declaration

CT 6251-6261: Declaration Of Gerald Armstrong (October 11, 1986)

October 11, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: Gerald Armstrong
View/Download: CT 6251-6261: Declaration Of Gerald Armstrong (October 11, 1986)
Exhibit to: EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF 20TH CAUSE OF ACTION; AND 13TH, 16TH, 17TH & 19TH CAUSES OF ACTION OF SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT VOLUME II (September 18, 1995)

 

Filed Under: Armstrong 4 Record on Appeal Tagged With: Armstrong 4 Record On Appeal Exhibit, By: Gerald Armstrong, Declaration, Gerald Armstrong Declaration

DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (October 11, 1986)

October 11, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: Gerald Armstrong
View/Download: DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (October 11, 1986)

 

[CT 6251]

I, Gerald Armstrong, declare:

1. I have been informed by my attorney, Julia Dragojevic, that attorneys for plaintiff Scientology organization have advised her that they intend to tell the Court that the organization has now fully complied with the Court’s orders of July 2, September 9 and December 9, 1985 regarding production of documents. The purpose of this declaration is to show that the Court’s orders have not been complied with.

2. I have reviewed the documents received from plaintiff organization as my “B-1″ file. This is offered by the organization as full compliance with original requests for production:

2. All originals and all copies of Guardians Office files pertaining to Gerald Armstrong.

3. All originals and all copies of correspondence of the Guardian’s Office pertaining to Gerald Armstrong.

Attached hereto as Exhibit [A] is a 14 page “time track” or chronology produced as part of the B-1 file. I have circled in red the date of 87 time track entries for which the documents from which they were extracted have been deleted from this “B- 1 file.”

3. “B-1″ was a designation, known from a certain level upwards in the organization, for the Guardians Office intelligence bureau. B-1 gathered intelligence internally and externally and overtly and covertly, and it ran agents and

-1-

[CT 6252]

carried out operations against enemies to frame them, compromise them, orotherwise nullify them as a threat. The GO also ran public relations, finance, legal, and they had, except for a couple o£ L. Ron Hubbard’s personal public relations officers, total control of any organization interfacing with government agencies, the media, law enforcement, private investigators, and enemies. The only thing the GO did not run was the auditing-training income-making apparatus of the organization. And that part of the organization would have no files on me. Within the GO each bureau had its own files. These files often related to enemies. “Freedom,” the organization’s tabloid black PR tool, was part of the GO. And the GO was itself a part and function of the Church of Scientology of California corporately and it was operated by Hubbard through his wife, the Controller. There has been a continuity in GO activities, and in many cases personnel, right to present time. The organization still puts out”Freedom,” it still does PR and black PR, it hires private investigators, lawyers, graphologists, etc., it has a finance bureau , and it has intelligence data gathering and covert operations; and it has files on me in each of these areas. Different organization units performing these functions from 1982 onward include Special Project, ASI, Religious Technology Center (RTC), Office of Special Affairs (OSA) (which is divided into OSA Pac(ific), OSA US, OSA Int(ernational), etc.), Mission All-Clear (MAC) (also with local, continental and international units), Commodore’s Messenger Organization (CMO) units, Watch-Dog Committee (WDC), and possibly others unknown. The corporation name personnel in these units supposedly worked for was

-2-

[CT 6253]

irrelevant since Hubbard, the GO, and the messengers who took over the GO functions in 1981 by-passed all corporate lines. The last time track entry in the “B-1″ file (see Exhibit [A]) is June 15, 1982. The organization had already begun its PI surveillance of Jocelyn and me, yet there is no time track reference to the PIs or their product. That the organization’s intelligence bureau was not running the PIs and not getting their product is a laughable impossibility. The real GO files on me, as for major enemies, would have been started in 1982. Before then there would have been an accumulation of some materials in my “B-1″ file, notably everything from the three weeks I was locked up on Hubbard’s order in B-1 at GO US in 1976, but even this plaintiff organization has failed to produce. In the spring and summer of 1982 the organization escalated the attack against me— the PI’s, the assaults, the attempted criminal charges with the LAPD, many meetings with organization personnel, the London operation, the “Armstrong Operation” (or Sherman-Ingrain Operation), more attempted criminal charges with the LA DA and the FBI, media campaigns, “Freedom” campaigns. Yet the documents the organization offers end, but for a few exceptions, in the spring of 1982. Each of the operations or attacks is GO province and function. Organization attorneys are trying to make believe that if the name changed the function disappeared. An analogy would be the War Department under FDR becoming the Department of Defense. The functions remained the same and there was, as in GO activities, continuity until present time. The B-1 file produced is a joke. The organization is asking me to believe that after it raised me in importance to

-3-

[CT 6254]

its number one or two enemy, all reports, correspondence, orders, evaluations, programs and operations concerning me ceased. The material received as “B-1″ is a small fraction of the documentation in the organization’s actual intelligence files on me. Then there are the PR and legal files.

4. I refer the court to my declaration of April 9, 1986 in which I listed various incidents, operations or publications which were clearly organization creations and concerning which the organization had produced no documents. The facts of that declaration, except for the subsequent receipt of the partial “B-1″ file, are essentially the same as they were then and I incorporate that declaration by reference herein. At page 14, no. 21 I described the documents still not produced concerning the “Armstrong Operation,” an organization intelligence operation which has been running from 1982 up to the present. The organization is still using the fruits of that operation, in fact, to make millions from its adherents (see p. 22, no. 6 of the April 1986 declaration). To prevent the organization from being able to completely sidestep the Court’s various orders regarding production of documents with the sham that the unproduced documents described in my declaration post-dated the renaming of the Guardians Office, Ms. Dragojevic served the organization’s attorneys with the request for production attached hereto as Exhibit [B]. This request lists the documents specified in my declaration as not produced in non-compliance with the Court’s orders. Request no. 21 asks for the documents relating to the “Armstrong Operation.” The organization’s response, signed by attorney John Peterson, is

-4-

[CT 6255]

attached hereto as Exhibit [C]. Mr. Peterson stated in response to request no. 21:

“Armstrong Operation” is a characterization invented by Cross-complainant as no such “operation” has ever existed. Cross-defendant has no such documents in its possession, custody or control.

This is such a big lie it boggles the mind. “Armstrong Operation” is the organization’s term: however the operation’s name is irrelevant. If the organization labelled the operation “Armstrong Program,” “Destroy GA Plan” or ” Freakout II,” it does not matter. Mr. Peterson knows what is being referred to because he was and is an active participant in the operation. He filed sworn declarations in this case and in many more across the country, and with several government agencies. He used his perverse rendition of the operation, in fact in the “Further Opposition to Motion to Compel Production of Documents” filed with this Court May 8, 1985. If Mr. Peterson is believed, that there are no documents concerning an operation over almost 6 years involving dozens of people, incredible expenditures of money for extra-legal actions, a bevy of PIs, three countries, illegal videotapes, bugs, a paid-off dirty cop, millions of “Freedom ” tabloids devoted to the operation distributed internationally, manufactured evidence foisted on the LAPD, LA DA, Courts and the FBI, and a get-rich-quick scheme involving millions of dollars internationally, he sends a message back to his client organization that lies still work and it is still good strategy to thwart and abuse legal procedures.

-5-

[CT 6256]

5. Attached hereto as Exhibit [D] is a series of daily reports concerning me from intelligence personnel in the Greater Los Angeles GO to posts in GO US covering the period from February 22 to March 18, 1982. This was before the first SP Declare was issued on me. As can be seen, intelligence daily reports were created for actions as simple as the stakeout of Omar Garrison’s residence even when nothing was observed. To say that the “Armstrong Operation” was created with no documentation, no orders and no funding, and that no reports were generated over four-plus years is beyond absurd. It should be noted that each of the individuals holding posts which received the reports or copies, also therefore possessed Armstrong documents and files.

6. Attached hereto as Exhibits [E], [F], [G] and [H] are documents entitled respectively “Juggernaut” Eval, Operation Freakout, Goodrich Suit Evaluation, and Christo Final Handling Eval. The Juggernaut document is a broad evaluation and program to attack Michael Flynn. The number of people involved is shown by the post distribution list on the first page. Freakout was an operation to frame a Scientology Critic, Paulette Cooper (PC) with a fake crime much as the organization has attempted with me on several occasions. The Goodrich document was written by Hubbard and is a model for attacking individuals with claims against the organization (see “Goodrich Eval” under the Policy section of the Juggernaut Eval). The same perfidious strategy used by the organization and its attorneys to invade my privacy cull and miscull my PC folders, and put the culled and misculled product, further distorted by their sinister minds, before the

-6-

[CT 6257]

Court, is devised and ordered by Hubbard at page 14 of this document. The Christo Final Handling Eval, which is clarified by my affidavit of March 8, 1985, also attached as part of Exhibit [H], concerns in part bringing criminal charges against Julie Christofferson, her associates and family, on Hubbard’s orders. The organization similarly attempted bringing false criminal charges against me. Julie Christofferson was in Scientology for a few months in a fringe franchise when she was 17 years old. Yet the organization in compliance with Hubbard’s orders created this sophisticated program to destroy her, including use of her auditing session statements against her (see p. 2, operating target 4 under Libby/Eureka, Montana). It is unimaginable that the organization has done all it has to me, operation after operation, yet has no evaluations, programs or operations files concerning me. The only other possibility is that the organization and its attorneys have, in anticipation or violation of the Court’s discovery orders, destroyed the evidence of their operations against me.

7. Mr. Peterson’s response regarding a manuscript, artwork and other materials stolen from the trunk of my car on November 8, 1984 (see request no. 15 of Exhibits B and C) is:

Cross-defendant has no knowledge of any burglary of Cross-complainant’s trunk. Hence, cross-defendant has no such documents in its possession custody or control.

Attached hereto as Exhibit [I] are a letter dated November 9, 1984 from Ms. Dragojevic to Mr. Peterson and his reply dated November 30, 1984. Ms. Dragojevic advises Mr. Peterson of the theft and

-7-

[CT 6258]

makes a demand for return of the materials stolen. He answers with accusations and threats. His claim now that his client has no knowledge of the burglary is just not true.

8. Another example of documents clearly withheld by plaintiff organization is in regards to the program to get the LA DA to bring criminal charges against me — ultimately to have me jailed. This is all part of the “Armstrong Operation.” At p. 23, no. 11 of the April 1986 declaration I showed, from the mouth of CSC, CSI, RTC and Hubbard attorney Earle C. Cooley, the existence of such documentation. The organization has produced none of these documents. A letter from the Office of the LA DA dated April 25, 1986, attached hereto as Exhibit [J], however, reveals that Mr. Peterson and organization personnel provided a mass of documentation, even more than I knew before then existed, to the DA. Mr. Peterson knows that I know because he got the DA’s letter. To consider that all this was done from no written orders, programs, evaluations or missions is madness. It should be noted that the recipients of the DA letter were all GO staff. Lyman Spurlock’s testimony at trial in 1984 that he (as ASI staff) and others got rid of the 1100 GO staff criminals is untrue. Ken Hoden was GO staff: in fact he was involved in the program on Hubbard’s orders to bring criminal charges against Julie Christofferson. Heber Jentzsch was a GO PR staffer for many years who was used for the organization’s frontal PR attacks on enemies. He continues to perform the same organization function. David Butterworth is a longtime GO staff member. When I knew him in the organization he was an aide to Mary Sue Hubbard in the Controller’s Office. John Peterson has been connected to

-8-

[CT 6259]

the GO from the 1970’s.

9. The organization has likewise still not produced the documents specified in connection with the other operations listed in my April 1986 declaration. I will not restate all these operations or the relevant documents, however, each operation is GO territory and each document relating to each operation fits squarely under the Court’s various discovery orders. I cannot consider that the orders have been complied with until the documents relating to all operations are received. There are literally thousands of documents being withheld by the organization and its attorneys.

10. What the organization also is doing to avoid exposure and compliance with discovery orders is to strip the plaintiff “corporation” of its personnel, functions, buildings, assets and files. When I left the organization, the Church of Scientology of California (CSC), under Hubbard, was the entire GO, Sea Organization, and all Scientology above small outer organizations and franchises, which were even then under CSC/Hubbard control. Attached hereto as Exhibit [K] are pages from the deposition of Cynthia Morrow, “managing agent” of CSC, taken October 29 and 30, 1985 in the case of Church of Scientology of California v. Jordan, LA Superior Court No. C538 049. Ms. Morrow testifies that by 1985 CSC had been stripped of all money-making organizations (service orgs) and was merely an “Office of Special Affairs.” In the Christofferson case in Portland, Oregon, former Executive Director International, William Franks testified that in December 1981 CSC had a net worth of $340 million and $150 million in one Sea Org Reserves

-9-

[CT 6260]

account alone. His testimony is attached hereto as Exhibit [L]. In the case of Wollersheim v. CSC, just tried in LA Superior Court, the organization submitted a financial statement, attached hereto as Exhibit [M], claiming a net worth for CSC of $18,667,947.00. On information and belief, in September CSC claimed that it had decreased its net worth another $6 million plus since the May financial statement was prepared, leaving a net worth of around $12 million. The organization’s various conveyances and corporate machinations, however, should not shield the organization from liability for its tortious and criminal acts, and should not provide an escape from non-compliance with discovery orders. The Court has already ruled on the alter ego issue in this case, and this reasoning is applicable to this discovery matter. The people who run CSC run all of Scientology, and they can produce any document having anything to do with me now in the possession of any Scientology unit, organization, corporation or individual.

11. Attached hereto as Exhibit [N] is an organization policy written by Hubbard entitled “Order Board and Time Machine.” In it Hubbard states as “a major policy:” “if it is not written, it is not true.” He goes on to set as policy: “Even when one gives a verbal order it is also written down.” There are literally dozens of organization policies insisting emphatically on the same thing: written orders, written compliances, written programs, written projects, written evaluations. Written orders, programs and missions are “word-cleared,”drilled,” and “done in clay” so they are fully understood. It is impossible with verbal orders or

-10-

[CT 6261]

reports. Even if the organization is hiding its orders, reports and files on me electronically in its computer system, and even if under my initials or a code designation, they exist. “If it isn’t written it isn’t true,” and the insistence on everything being in writing is hard policy in all Scientology organizations. Virtually nothing except for body functions, at the Sea Org/GO/OSA/CSC level is done without written orders and a written record.

12. The organization’s strategy, beyond its direct attacks aimed at my personal destruction, is to lie and stonewall to hopefully delay the January 1987 trial, or make it, with obstructions of all kinds, unbelievably difficult to try the case.

The organization and its attorneys, who accuse me of conspiracy, are the conspirators in this paranoid and dangerous plan to thwart legal redress of their victims. The Court can move along the case and the discovery matters, and the organization’s assault on sanity and justice can be checked by enforcing full compliance with its various orders, and the intent of the law.

I declare under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.

Executed this llth day of October, 1986 at Boston, Massachusetts.

[signed]
Gerald Armstrong

-11-

Exhibit [A] B-1 “Time Track” Chronology

Exhibit [B]Request for Production of Documents 08-04-1986

Exhibit [C]Response to Request for Production of Documents 09-02-1986

Exhibit [D]B-1 Daily Reports [Clerk’s Transcript Pages 6262 – 6275]

Exhibit [E] Juggernaut Eval [.pdf]

Exhibit [F] Operation Freakout

Exhibit [G] Goodrich Suit Evaluation [pdf]

Exhibit [H] Christo Final Handling Eval [pdf]

Exhibit [I] Letter from Ms. Dragojevic to Mr. Peterson 11-09-1984

Exhibit [J] Letter from Office of the LA DA 04-25-1986 [pdf]

Exhibit [K] Cynthia Morrow deposition (excerpt) 10-29-1985, 10-30-1985

Exhibit [L] Testimony William Franks 12-1981

Exhibit [M] Scientology’s financial statement submitted in Wollersheim v. CSC

Exhibit [N] HCO PL 1 May 1965 Order Board and Time Machine © 1965 L. Ron Hubbard

Filed Under: Armstrong 1 Tagged With: B-1 Files, By: Gerald Armstrong, Case No. C 420153, Declaration, Discovery, Gerald Armstrong Declaration

DECLARATION [of John G. Peterson] SUPPORTING ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM RE: DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL DOUGLAS (October 9, 1986)

October 9, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: John G. Peterson, Esq.
View/Download: DECLARATION [of John G. Peterson] SUPPORTING ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM RE: DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL DOUGLAS (October 9, 1986)

 

Filed Under: Armstrong 1 Tagged With: By: John G. Peterson Esq., Case No. C 420153, Declaration, Discovery, Michael Douglas

DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (September 24, 1986)

September 24, 1986 by Clerk2

Author: Gerald Armstrong
View/Download: DECLARATION OF GERALD ARMSTRONG (September 24, 1986)

 

Filed Under: Armstrong 1 Tagged With: By: Gerald Armstrong, Case No. C 420153, Declaration, Discovery, Gerald Armstrong Declaration

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 58
  • Page 59
  • Page 60
  • Page 61
  • Page 62
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 72
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Settlement signing (December 6, 1984)
Armstrong 1
Armstrong 2
Armstrong 3
Armstrong 4
Armstrong 5
Armstrong 6
Armstrong 7
Armstrong 8
Related Cases
Sworn Testimony

Footer

Documents By Date

Armstrong cases

  • Armstrong 1
  • Armstrong 1 Appeals
  • Armstrong 2
  • Armstrong 2 Appeal
  • Armstrong 3
  • Armstrong 4
  • Armstrong 4 Appeals
  • Armstrong 4 Record on Appeal
  • Armstrong 5
  • Armstrong 6
  • Armstrong 6 Appeals
  • Armstrong 7
  • Armstrong 7 Appeals
  • Armstrong 8
  • Index
  • Related Litigation

Pages

  • Home
  • Scientology v. Armstrong: Record on Appeal

Tags

**Hubbard Biography Project** (80) Affidavit (95) Armstrong 1 Correspondence (110) Armstrong 1 Documents Under Seal (98) Armstrong 1 Trial Exhibit (Defendant) (79) Armstrong 1 Trial Exhibit (Joint) (115) Armstrong 4 Correspondence (77) Armstrong 4 Record on Appeal (189) Armstrong 4 Record On Appeal Exhibit (861) Armstrong Exhibit (132) Aznaran (136) By: Andrew H. Wilson Esq. (185) By: Clerk Of Court (80) By: Ford Greene Esq. (396) By: Gerald Armstrong (598) By: John G. Peterson Esq. (86) By: Julia Dragojevic Esq. (98) By: L. Ron Hubbard (111) By: Laurie J. Bartilson Esq. (433) By: Michael J. Flynn Esq. (72) By: Paul Morantz Esq. (89) Case No. 95-1164 (70) Case No. 152229 (120) Case No. 157680 (358) Case No. BC 052395 (239) Case No. C 420153 (305) Case No. CV 021632 (118) Complaint (75) Declaration (575) Deposition (153) Discovery (91) Fair Game (81) Flynn (85) Gerald Armstrong (70) Gerald Armstrong Declaration (149) Gerald Armstrong Deposition (101) Letter (178) Minute Order (104) Motion (129) Notice (76) Opposition (105) Order (141) Points and Authorities (131) Reply (71) Reporter's Transcript Of Proceedings (83)
  • Scientology v. Armstrong

Copyright © 2026 · Infinity Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

imunify-bot-check